Indulge in the ultimate chocolate lover’s treat with these decadent Reese’s Triple Chocolate Cookies. Made with semi sweet, milk, and white chocolate PLUS Reese’s Pieces and peanut butter chips, these cookies are a chocolate and peanut butter lover’s dream come true.
When we were moving from Lehi I was trying to work my way through our pantry, fridge and freezer as much as possible so we’d have less to move into a new house. And less spillage, leakage etc haha. I found a random container with little bits of all those chocolates and thought, oh I’m soooo making cookies that the kids can share with friends. Instead, we ate them all!
We use chocolate pudding powder to make these cookies extra tender and chewy. Just like our chocolate chip pudding cookies, these cookies have the perfect texture…a little crispy around the edges and fudgy on the insides!
Ingredients for Reese’s Triple Chocolate Cookies
I originally was going to call these chocolate kitchen sink cookies because it felt like I tossed everything in except the kitchen sink, but traditional kitchen sink cookies usually have oats, so I left the kitchen sink at home…haha! Suffice it to say, these cookies have a little bit of everything chocolate and peanut butter. Here is what you will need:
- Butter: I prefer to use unsalted butter, but if you only have salted on hand, just reduce the salt by 1/4 teaspoon.
- Eggs: give structure to the cookies
- White Sugar: adds sweetness
- Brown Sugar: firmly pack the brown sugar before adding it to the dough
- Vanilla Extract: adds flavor
- Flour: just regular all purpose flour
- Salt: enhances all the flavors and offsets the sweetness
- Baking Soda: acts as a leavening agent to give the cookies rise and chewiness
- Cocoa Powder: boosts the fudgy chocolate flavor
- Instant Chocolate Pudding Mix: adds more chocolate flavor and helps keep the cookies moist
- Add-Ins: Reese’s Pieces, White Chocolate Chips, Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips, Milk Chocolate Chips and Peanut Butter Chips (Reese’s Peanut Butter Chips are our favorite)
The measurements for all of these ingredients can be found in the recipe card at the end of this post.
Step By Step Instructions for Making These Cookies
Making these chocolate Reese’s cookies is easy and straightforward. Here are the basic steps:
- Prep: Preheat the oven and line some baking sheets with parchment paper or silpats.
- Wet Ingredients: In the bowl of a stand mixer, add all the wet ingredients (butter, eggs, sugars and vanilla) and mix until combined.
- Dry Ingredients: In a separate bowl, whisk together all the dry ingredients (flour, salt, baking soda, cocoa and pudding mix).
- Combine: Add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients and mix until just barely combined and a few streaks of the flour mixture remain.
- Fold: Add the Reese’s Pieces and all the baking ships and fold into the cookie dough.
- Scoop: Use a large cookie scoop and scoop out cookie dough balls and roll into a perfect ball.
- Bake: Bake the cookies for 8-10 minutes, then allow them to cool for 3 minutes on the sheet before moving them to a wire rack to cool.
All of these instructions in complete detail can be found in the recipe at the end of the post.
Tips for Making the Best Triple Chocolate Cookies
It’s very important that you purchase INSTANT pudding and not the cook and serve kind. The cook and serve style of pudding simply won’t work for this recipe.
When adding in the instant pudding mix, add it like any other dry ingredient. You don’t actually make the pudding mix like it says on the box. Just stir it into the dough like you would flour.
The baking chips you add can be pretty much anything you have left over. See section below for more ideas.
Don’t overbake the cookies. They won’t need more than 8-10 minutes and will cook a little more on the sheet pan as they cool.
Variations
If you don’t have Reese’s Pieces or you’re not a fan of white chocolate chips, all the add-ins are totally interchangeable. Other options might include:
- Peanut Butter m&m’s (I saw they have mini peanut butter m&m’s now!)
- Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups (chopped up)
- Dark Chocolate Chips
- Regular m&m’s
- Toffee Bits
- Chopped Peanuts
How Do You Keep Cookies Soft?
To keep homemade cookies soft, let them cool completely before storing them.
Put the cooled cookies in an air-tight container for storage. If they start to dry out, stick a slice of bread in the container with the cookies.
How Long Will Cookies Keep?
Properly stored in an airtight container, freshly baked cookies will last for about 2 to 3 weeks at normal room temperature. They also freeze well if you want them to last longer. Place them on a single layer on a baking sheet and freeze for 2 hours. Then stack them in a freezer safe container, and they will keep for up to 3 months.
If you are looking for thick and chewy chocolate cookies that are fully loaded with all things peanut butter and chocolate, then these Reese’s triple chocolate cookies are your new best friend!
More COOKIE RECIPES You’re Going to Love:
- Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Chocolate Chip Pudding Cookies
- Cinnamon Roll Cookies
- Soft Gingerbread Cookies
- Glazed Lemon Cookies
- Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Thick Snickerdoodle Cookies
- Nutella and Dulce de Leche Stuffed Cookies
- Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Lemon Drop Cookies
- Best Cut Out Sugar Cookies
- Copycat Swig Sugar Cookies
- Oatmeal Raisin Chocolate Chip Cookies
- All our COOKIE RECIPES here!
Reese’s Triple Chocolate Cookies
Description
Ingredients
- 2 Cups Butter, unsalted, softened (4 sticks)
- 4 Large Eggs
- 1 1/2 Cups White Sugar
- 2 Cups Brown Sugar
- 2 teaspoons Vanilla Extract
- 5 Cups All Purpose Flour, like Gold Medal
- 2 teaspoons Salt
- 2 teaspoons Baking Soda
- 1/2 Cup Cocoa
- 1 Box Instant Chocolate Pudding Mix, 5.1oz box, fudge or devil's food
- 1 Cup Reese's Pieces
- 1/2 Cup White Chocolate Chips
- 1/2 Cup Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips
- 1/2 Cup Milk Chocolate Chips
- 1/2 Cup Peanut Butter Chips
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper or silpats.
- In a bowl of a standing mixer, combine the butter, eggs, sugars, and vanilla in large bowl until evenly mixed.2 Cups Butter, 4 Large Eggs, 1 1/2 Cups White Sugar, 2 Cups Brown Sugar, 2 teaspoons Vanilla Extract
- In a separate bowl, whisk together the flour, salt, baking soda, cocoa and pudding mix.5 Cups All Purpose Flour, 2 teaspoons Salt, 2 teaspoons Baking Soda, 1/2 Cup Cocoa, 1 Box Instant Chocolate Pudding Mix
- Add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients and mix until just combined then add the Reese's Pieces and all the baking ships and fold in.1 Cup Reese's Pieces, 1/2 Cup White Chocolate Chips, 1/2 Cup Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips, 1/2 Cup Milk Chocolate Chips, 1/2 Cup Peanut Butter Chips
- Using a 1/4 cup cookie scoop to make the perfect ball, scoop the cookies onto the baking sheet. Roll the cookies into balls so they have that shine on the outside after they bake.
- Bake for 8-10 minutes and allow to cool for 3 minutes then remove to a cooling rack and repeat with remaining dough.
Notes
Nutrition
Recommended Products
Tasha Ramp
I only have instant vanilla pudding mix on hand. Could I use that and maybe just add a little extra cocoa? 🙂 I really want to make these cookies but it’s -6* here and I am not going anywhere in this frigid air! 🙂
Sweet Basil
Oh, there’s no way I’d leave my house! I actually used instant a few times and it was still great.
Ashton
Ok, I want all of these in my mouth right now!! omg!
Sweet Basil
And that’s pretty much what I did. I have no self control
brooke
I don’t remember any specific dreams but my boss wake up crying hysterically at least 3x a week. I can’t wake them, I can’t calm them, they look right through me like I’m not there. It’s when they settle down and just stare at me that it gets sleet creepy. They don’t answer any questions, just stare. Then lay down and go back to sleep on their own.
Haley
I’m pregnant with my first kiddo, so she hasn’t had dreams to tell me about yet! Unfortunately I have had weird dreams thanks to her though! I woke up in a boat and was surrounded by alligators. I then had to jump past the alligators to get to land because the boat was sinking. When I got on to land I saw that my car was crushed and flipped upside down floating in the water! I’m not sure what all of that meant, but it was freaky!
Erin M.
I can’t recall any weird dreams at the moment but I used to sleep walk as a child…very unnerving!
Becky Blad
My son only recently starting talking about his dreams. He is young. But he had his first nightmare and woke up upset. The details of his dream weren’t clear but he said I was in the kitchen and threw tortillas on the floor. Apparently that’s really scary!
Dayanna
Those cookies look incredible! My daughter is too young to remember any dreams at the moment but when I was younger I had this dream of being in some strange town with lots of older ladies it was so weird!
Kristy Ferguson
One of my twins has night terrors and one night she starts screaming in turn causes the other twin to wake up and starts screaming because she doesn’t know what’s going on. She comes running, screaming down the hall terrified. She gets to our door and my husband jumps out of bed and starts yelling “what’s going on! What’s going on!?!” Then my teenage son burst out of his room to see what all the commotion is. Soon after the baby starts crying. Needless to say our entire house was awake because of this and the one who started it had no clue it even happened!
Jenni
I can’t remember any weird dreams at the moment, but I know we have all had them.My cute little 5 year old just told me he had a dream last night that he was in candyland and he was made out of gingerbread and his stuffed animal was frosting and it was a good dream. Love this recipe, anything with peanut butter and chocolate has to be delicious!
Gina McGary
My son has a reoccurring nightmare that he’s a sleepover at his cousins house and he ran to our house to grab his pillow. On the way back a huge black dog with red eyes jumps infront of him and says, “you’re next!”
keri
My kids will love these!!
Kim
My son is two so he doesn’t tell me about his dreams but he has often told me he was busy saving the day when he first wakes up:)
Jenna
These cookies look so delicious. My husband would love these, as he loves Reese’s!
amy pugmire
I have heard my middle daughter (4years) talking in her sleep saying “no, no” and she has woken up for about 3 weeks in a row in the middle of the night screaming bloody murder! I honestly thought someone was trying to hurt her and I usually to hold and rock her for about an hour to get her to calm down and go back to sleep. MY oldest will wake up telling me she has a bad dream that the bad guys came and got her. (freaks me out) The night terrors have rested for a few days hopefully mama can get some good sleep. 🙂
L Sloan
My daughter used to have nightmares about falling out of a helicopter. She says she still does occasionally and she’s a grown woman now.
Amy b
These look soo good. cooksooI have a bunch of reeses in the freezer, just waiting and calling my name 🙂
My 2.5 year old daughter woke up screaming one night and said “there is a light over there, and I can’t see baby Jesus because he is in his car.” What? So weird. 🙂
Shaelyn
Too funny. These look heavenly, I will def be day dreaming about these today as the snow keeps falling. I may even trek on over in the snow to get all of the ingredients! Yum
Callie
These cookies look absolutely amazing! I love on and chocolate, so I’m sure these will be a hit! Heading to the store today to get some! My little is only 7 months old, so nothing crazy yet, but my husband has night terrors…it is so scary, because he’ll wake up in a full panic that something is happening to him…on time he had a nightmare he was tossed into a pit of snakes and kept yelling please don’t bite me and was trying to throw them off! Bless his heart!
carrian
Congratulations! You’re our winner. Please email me within 24 hours to claim your prize at ohsweetbasil (at) gmail.com
MaryEllen
For several months when I asked my 3 yr old what he dreamt about he’d say ‘Jesus & trains.’ I ask him to give me more info & he’d say ‘Jesus’ train is white & mine is blue. We’d play trains.’ Kind of cool & kind of wild!
Margett Eichmann
No real weird dreams from my kiddos but did have a daughter sleep walking out the kitchen door into the garage. By the time we got to her she was trying so very hard to,try and lift the garage door.
Danielle
My 9 year old had an odd dream about chuckie (from chuckie cheese lol) that he was playing weird music and just “acting creepy” in his own words lol. Guess a giant mouse can be pretty weird when you thinking about it.
Lynda M.
Reeses and cookies – a match made in heaven! Pinning and printing now!
Caroll salazar
I’m actually expecting my first child ☺️She’s due this February and I can’t wait for her to share her dreams with me☺️Great recipe by the way! I love recess cups and I’m sure I will love these cookies will Definetly bake these soon and share them on Instagram ☺️ So since my baby girl isn’t born yet, I’ll share about my niece dream, she is 11 years old and had dreamed that she was at barn far away from home with a lot of animals that would speak to her, so weird but pretty awesome too lol
Amber @ rick•a•bam•boo
My oldest is 2 but he will wake up crying and day he had a bad dream. For a couple weeks he would wake up screaming, but luckily that hadn’t happened in a while. These Reese’s cookies look delicious. I am sure the two-year-old would love them. He’s a big fan of peanut butter.
Shemp DeYoung
When she was a toddler, my daughter was asleep and I heard her talking in her sleep. “No thank you. No thank you. I SAID NO THANK YOU!”
Before they went to sleep I often made up stories about the adventures of Timon & Pumba. It seems that Pumba was trying to get her to eat some “very juicy grubs.”
“Daddy, I tried the crunchy bugs and they were pretty gross, but there was no way I was gonna eat those gooey ones!”
jam
i don’t have kid…but my one weird dream had as a kid was talking to big bird of sesame street about how we were in a dream, that this was adream and this is not real and that i was sleeping!
Melanie
I wish I had a cool story to share!!! My oldest is only 4! The only bad dream he ever had was apparently when Fire was on his body and he was climbing up the walls to stay away from the lava. By the way, he helped me bake these cookies tonight and they were a huge hit! Perfect balance of chocolate and peanut butter flavor. Totally making again!!!
Myla
These cookies look delicious!!! My husband would LOVE them! I’ll have to make these next!
cree
I couldn’t even read any of the other comments. I get scared easily
Lori Kenney
My son tells me he has nightmares so that I’ll stay in his room for awhile, I know it can’t be true because he barely puts his head down and calls me to his room. And now his sister has caught on and uses the nightmare thing to say she doesn’t want to go to sleep! Ugh!
Raine
When my daughter was about kindergarten age she’d always have conversations with ‘the man in the black hat’, I’d ask what they were talking about and she told me he’d tell her stories about her grandma Edna. This completely freaked all of us out because that was my great grandmother who passed away before she was born and we turned my great gram’s room into hers. She said they were planting flowers in her dreams but she’d start crying because she was sad that she couldn’t help because the prickers hurt her hands. No one in the family has a clue about the man. I myself have night terrors and they’re awful!
Allison
That pie tho!!!!
Sarah
I don’t have kids yet but the weirdest dream I’ve had as of late was flying on a plane to meet P.Diddy and pitch an after school program proposal and promising to make him my caramel apple cheesecake cupcakes.
Jen worden
I was going to comment. But I’m distracted by my grotesque need for excessive amounts of Reese’s cups.
My 4yo got to experience his first chocolate advent calendar this past christmas. He would wake up and bring me the calendar to tell me “it’s a new day” and ask for a chocolate as soon as his eyes opened.
This AM. He ran to his snack cabinet. Grabbed a Reese’s and brought it to me in bed. Mommy can I have this treat because I woke up?
Yes. Waking up is a big deal. Yea you may
Audrey Crisp
My kids have never told me about their nightmares her…. 3 and 21 months, but those cookies look amazing!
Genesis
Oh my goodness I’m definitely going to make these today! They look soo good!
Amy P
My daughters often have crazy dreams, usually stemming from something they read or watched in the recent past, so it can be anything such as polar bears (Lost) running around in mazes (Maze-Runner)
Kit
My daughter dreamed that the cat was trying to steal her doll. Lol ps the cookies look yummy!
Janelle Belka
My kids both have crazy dreams sometimes but I can’t remember any one in particular.
Kayla
Chocolate and peanut butter is my favorite combo. These cookies look so good. I’ll have to make a half batch, so I don’t ruin my diet too tremendously! TFS!
Kayla
Wanted to add as I don’t have any children, I remember a really scary dream I had when I was young. At a sleepover at my aunt’s house, which was really creepy, I had a dream about a witch. All I remember was just the witch, but it woke me out of a sound sleep and there was a triangular shadow on the wall. That’s probably why I still remember because I was so scared.
leighann
My 4 year old son’s latest dream, he was a booger sales man. Who lives in a booger house. His favorite and best seller-Zebra boogers. Black and white striped, but they aren’t actual boogers they are Zebras that are teeny tiny.
Brittany C
My kids are too young to remember and recall their dreams just yet, but I am sure looking forward to hearing about them, cuz if they’re anything like their crazy momma dreams I am in for a treat! Lol
Alanna Staffel
So… I dont have any kids yet, but just the other night I dreamed I was in a video game fighting the devil to free child slaves… NO clue why! Lol
Staci
My son had night terrors for a long time. One time he kept freaking out because his hands were turning into squares
Angelica Iniguez
Whoa. These look delicious! I will definitely have to try these tomorrow! 🙂
Taylor
I don’t have any kids but one of my craziest dreams I had was when I was younger. It was around Halloween time and I had already decided what I wanted to be. I had a dream that it was Halloween and I dressed up as a bunny. I was dressed in all white but however in my dream I fell into a giant mud puddle. I came you a chocolate bunny. After that I refused to dress up as the white bunny because I was afraid I was going to fall into a mud puddle. So my mom had to go find me a new costume to wear for Halloween.
Matti Smith
My son has regular dreams that he is “the special” from The Lego Movie….only he’s trying to save penguins stuck in trees, or random talking soccer balls. always different dreams…but he’s usually The Special in all of them. So weird!
Chelsea Alexander
My daughter is two and she’s had weird ones already. Like, she woke up crying because she dreamt the dog was biting her (he sleeps locked in his kennel….And he’s 10lbs) and another time that we were flying and she was falling. Insane for a 2 1/2 year old!
Suzi Barkley
My 5 year old had a dream that he was dancing and singing the song on the movie Ghostbuster’s and the marshmallow man and slider were dancing with him. 🙂
Suzi Barkley
He dreamed about a little girl named Scary Mary. If he looked in a mirror and said her name, she would come and tickle his feet. He can’t sleep now without a lamp on in his room.
Lindsay Coates
My kiddos are too little to tell me about their dreams but I will never forget one time when my little sister woke us all up screaming so bad I thought she was being kidnapped or something. Come to find out there were giant worms attacking her (which we later found out we’re the strings on her blanket!) she still swears they were real killer worms! Haha
Kaitlin
I should probably break my New Years resolution and make these
Tori
First off, these look amaZing! I can’t wait to make some, I especially want to make some for my dad to try. He loves anything Reese’s (:
So, my son is 2 1/2 and can’t really
Tell me about dreams yet. But oh my, I have the strangest, most detailed dreams. All. The. Time. Ha. My dreams always have so much detail they seem real. I don’t think I’m not sure if I can pick just one strange dream.
Here is a repeating dream I used to have. I’m a vegetarian and have been for 6 Years now. I used to dream for like two months straight I was eating some type of meat, usually hamburgers. And this was about 2 years after I became a vegetarian.
Kelsey potter
I totally get ya on the no sleep thing. I have a 1 yr old who still wakes every 2 hrs
Shannon
I don’t have a child but one of my craziest dreams ever was been trapped in the elevator at our local sports stadium and the quarterback came and rescued me as he was the only one that had strong enough arms to open up the elevator. Now whenever I watch him play, I think about the time he saved me in the elevator.
Ashley Calloway
Yummmmmy! I am a serious cookie addict. No shame. ✌
Michelle
Those cookies look delicious! I might have make some soon!
Rachel
my one year old obviously can’t tell me about his dreams. but I’m pregnant with number 2 and having the weirdest dreams. the weirdest I went in for an ultrasound and the dr said well it’s twins and on the screen it was like 2 adults dancing and partying around like the prank jimmy kimmel did on his aunt. I woke up crying because i had full grown mini humans walking in my stomach ha ha!
Kathleen Reichle
My daughter had a night terror when she was little. Scariest dream of *my* life! She just kept screaming telling me she wanted her mom, eyes wide open the whole time. I Kept telling her I was her mom but she kept trying to push away from me. I called my mom in tears. My daughter finally stopped dreaming and quieted down and didn’t remember any of it the next day. Thank goodness she never had another one. As for me, I’m going to be dreaming about your cookies tonight. They look yummy!
Brooke T
My daughter has reoccurring dreams about butterflies chasing her but not in the good way!
Ashley Wright
My kids are too young to really tell me about their dreams, but my two year old is really good at sleep walking! That keeps my life interesting! 😉
Judith Asuncion
The weirdest dream I ever had is that my front tooth fall off & in my culture they say when you have a dream like that somebody in your family or relatives will die & coincidently my great grandma died that day. It’s the kinda dream I don’t wanna have anymore.
Anne
My kids are still a little young to be able to share their dreams – but I get a lot of giggling, crying, and talking.
My oldest son did try to pee on his laundry basket once, while asleep. That was fun!!!
Kayle (The Cooking Actress)
aw poor thing!! My brother. one time, had a dream where the burger he had eaten before was chasing after him and trying to eat HIM (he sat straight up in bed during this nightmare and yelled “RUN FOR THE TASTE!”)
and these cookies are as delicious as your daughter’s dreams are insane! LOVE how choco-peanut buttery these are
Sweet Basil
HAHA!! Did that really happen? That’s awesome!
Christina @ The Beautiful Balance
YIKES!! I had night terrors growing up and I’m 26 now and had one a few weeks ago. Needless to say my dog and boyfriend are terrified when I go to sleep now. It’s scary, but the best thing you can do is to just rub her back and not talk about it until she’s fully conscious and a different day. I had the same night terror over and over and over growing up and I was never scared until I woke up, even though my family or whoever I was standing over thought I was awake the whole time because my eyes were open. Once I managed to flip my bed upside down and half was on the floor and my mom came in to me laying on top of it with my eyes open. She was terrified and we don’t know how or why I flipped the bed. Weird stuff.
Sweet Basil
Holy moly!! That would freak me out as the parent!
Jenny
About a month ago my 5 yo daughter came to the breakfast table talking about a dream she had where her and her brother were playing in the snow building a snowman. She started talking to her 7 yr old brother about the good time they had like he was really there and it really happened. I tried explaining to my daughter that her brother was not really there in her dream and that is when my son piped up and told me he was there he had met his sister in his dream and they played the snow together building a snowman. I thought they were joking with me so I separated them and asked them specific questions about the snowman and area they were in,they both told me the exact same answers.
Sweet Basil
That’s crazy!
Fatimah
We moved in to a new rental house & my then 2.5-year-old daughter woke up in tears in the middle of the night. She sobbed that there was a ‘shadow in her closet”. I didn’t think much of it. Happens with a move..normal stuff, right? Right. The next day I realized our new backyard backs into a cemetery that is over 200 years old. Yikes. Shadow in her closet..whaaaat?!
Sweet Basil
Ok, that is so creepy!
Brittney
I am a sleep walker and talker too! I have lots of strange dreams, but the weirdest one I can think of off the top of my head was from a few month ago. I thought there was a spider playing the banjo on my head board. I wish I was joking. These kind of dreams happen all the time, at least twice a week!
Sweet Basil
Bahahahahaha!! That’s hilarious!
Bryn
My 2 year old was having a terrible time with allergies turning into colds and then into ear infections. I was instructed to give her Benadryl before bed to help dry her up a bit. The first night…no big deal. Second night she started screaming and I went and picked her up and she was looking over my shoulder pointing and screaming “get me away from him!” I couldn’t soothe her or calm her down. Same thing next night. Turns out some little ones can get night terrors or hallucinations on Benadryl. Obviously we quickly found alternative solutions :). Other than that both girls have frilly princess dreams.
Pudding mix cookies are always big hits here. Will def be trying soon.
Sweet Basil
no. way. That is so crazy! I had no idea that could happen. We haven’t used benadryl but I don’t think I want to try now!
Megan
Those cookies look good, I rarely make a chocolate base cookie but I think I’ll give these a try-we love the chocolate/peanut butter combo in this house (who doesn’t though?!). My daughter is only two so she hasn’t told me any specific dream details but lately she will tell me things like “There was somebody in my room” when I get her up in the morning which is kind of creepy to me!!
Sweet Basil
Holy creepy!! I would totally be weirded out by that!